How to Start a Small Business in Valley Cottage, NY (2023 Guide)

LLCBase is your go-to place for everything about LLCs, and it's led by Brian Cohan, who's an expert in the field. Brian and our team are here to give you clear and helpful advice on how to set up and manage an LLC. We've been through the process and know the ins and outs. Our articles and guides are based on real experiences, making them practical for you. We're committed to helping you make smart choices for your business. With LLCBase, you're in good hands as you navigate the world of LLCs.

Start a Small Business in Valley Cottage City

Starting a small business in Valley Cottage, NY: Whether you want to diversify your career or become an entrepreneur, starting a small business will always be a unique idea. Small businesses require less funding; they are cost-effective and easier to start. If you’re considering starting a small business in Valley Cottage, NY, there are some important points you need to consider before taking the first step.

Valley Cottage, located in New York state, is one of the places that is favorable for entrepreneurs. With a population of 8749 (approx), the place has diverse work opportunities. Starting a small business in Valley Cottage is a good opportunity if you choose a proper business type. Starting a business involves a few steps, including having a solid business plan. Remember, it is not worth spending the money and time if you don’t have a proper plan, especially if you’re a beginner.

LLCBase Team has come up with a simple step-by-step guide on how to start a small business in Valley Cottage, NY. From conducting market research to securing the necessary permits, this guide will provide a roadmap to get your business off the ground in Valley Cottage.

Start a Small Business in Valley Cottage, NY

Small businesses are not so difficult to start in Valley Cottage. As mentioned earlier, it is easy, less complicated, and of course, needs little or no money to set up a small business in Valley Cottage, NY. If you consider filing your small business with the New York Secretary of State, choosing a limited liability company would be better. Starting an LLC is much easier and less expensive than any other form of business.

In many regions of New York, especially major cities, Delivery services is the most favorable business to start. If you’re in the capital of the state, Albany, you have immense opportunities to start your Delivery services business. On the other side, some of the businesses, such as Merchandise Reseller, Mobile business, Trucking Business, and Daycare Center are favorable in many other parts of New York state.

Now, let’s look at the demography of Valley Cottage. The percentage of the female population (50.7%) to the percentage of the male population (49.3%) is kind of useful for any business to start in Valley Cottage. For some businesses, this percentage plays a pivotal role in anticipating future revenue. This is one of the crucial facts you need to know before your business hits the ground in the city.

On the other hand, looking at the income of households in Valley Cottage, 58.8% of people make a six-figure income in a year. If you are about to set up businesses like Delivery services in Valley Cottage, you get a clear idea of who can be your potential customer. Following are some important stats and facts about Valley Cottage, NY.

Important Statistics in Valley Cottage, NY

Household Income (%)

Household Income $150k+36.4%
Household Income $100k-150k22.4%
Household Income $75k-100k12.1%
Household Income $50k-75k9.3%
Average (Median) Individual Income57983

Education and Employment (%)

Unemployment Rate (%)6.9%
Labour Force Participation (%)62.7%
College or Above (%)52.1%
Graduate (%)23.7%
Stem Degree (%)42.9%
Bachelor (%)28.4%

Overall Stats:

  • Population in the 30s: 10.9 (in millions)
  • Population in the 40s: 11.6 (in millions)
  • College graduates: 23.7%
  • Family Average Income (Median): 117500
  • Valley Cottage Unemployment rate: 6.9%
  • Poverty rate count: 2.4

These statistics are estimated and taken from various sources across the internet. It is recommended to verify the data before you take this into consideration.

Recommended Read: Start a Small Business in Cortez, CO

How to Start a Small Business in Valley Cottage, NY

To start a small business in Valley Cottage, you must go through a few steps. You can perform these steps independently or hire business formation services to do it for you. You’ll find many such providers in New York. You can explore the best LLC services in New York. They are proficient and experienced in forming all types of businesses, from small to large in size. Some leading companies offer New York LLC formation at $0. Following are the steps to start a small business in Valley Cottage:

Step 1: Research and Planning

Before diving into the world of entrepreneurship, it’s crucial to conduct thorough market research to determine the feasibility of your business idea. Identify your target market, assess your product or service demand, and analyze the competition in Valley Cottage, NY. This research works for you to understand your customers’ needs, preferences, and purchasing habits, allowing you to tailor your offerings accordingly.

Also, create a comprehensive business plan outlining your company’s goals, strategies, and financial projections. A very well-balanced business plan will serve as a roadmap to your new business and help you secure funding from investors or financial institutions.

Getting a business idea before you proceed to the next step is important. The top 5 businesses in New York are, Delivery services, Merchandise Reseller, Mobile business, Trucking Business, and Daycare Center respectively. If the city/town you are in has demand for any of the businesses mentioned above, you can easily start it at a very minimum cost.

Step 2: Legal Considerations

Next, you must address the legal aspects of starting a business in Valley Cottage, NY. You must decide on the legal business structure, like Partnership, Sole Proprietorship, Limited Liability Company (LLC), or corporation. Each structure has its own advantages and disadvantages, so consult with a business attorney or accountant to determine the most suitable option for your specific circumstances. Forming an LLC for small businesses is desirable as it offers better tax benefits than other structures.

Register your business under proper offices, such as the Valley Cottage Clerk’s Office or the New York Secretary of State’s Office. If available, you can file your business online through New York Secretary of State online portal. Obtain the necessary licenses and permits in New York and Valley Cottage to operate legally in your industry. These requirements vary depending on the nature of your business, so it’s important to research and comply with all applicable regulations.

2a. Name Your Business in Valley Cottage

Every business needs a proper and good name. When you start a business, you must name it as per the type and nature of the business. Before you name your business in Valley Cottage, NY, make sure your name is available for use. There are ways to find if the business name is available in New York or Valley Cottage. You can attempt a business name search in New York by using the Secretary of State online portal.

2b. Appoint a Registered Agent

registered-agents

Every business needs a registered agent who will receive official documents from the government on behalf of the company. The Resident Agent is a person that must have a physical address in New York state. The person should be above 18 years old and must have a permit to work in the New York. Several business formation services in Valley Cottage provide registered agent services at reasonable prices. You can explore the best registered agents in New York to choose the best one for you.

2c. File Formation Document

fomation-document

The next step is to file your formation documents with the New York SOS. If you’re forming a sole proprietorship for your small business, you can skip the registration part. A sole proprietorship does not require formal registration. You must register your business for others, like corporations, LLCs, or nonprofits. For an LLC, you must file the New York Articles of Organization, and for the Corporation, you must file the New York Certificate of Incorporation with New York Secretary of State.

Step 3: Finances and Funding

Starting a small business often requires initial capital to cover equipment, inventory, marketing, and office space expenses. Assess your financial situation and determine how much funding you’ll need to launch your business. Explore different financing options, including personal savings, bank loans, grants, and angel investors. In Valley Cottage, you will find New York small business loans and New York small business grants to get the funding you need. You can also get funded through private investors in Valley Cottage, NY. There are companies, organizations, and individuals that invest in small businesses to make a good amount of money.

Consider creating a detailed financial forecast that outlines your projected revenue, expenses, and cash flow for the first few years of operation. This will help you manage your finances effectively and demonstrate your business’s potential to potential investors or lenders.

Step 4: Location and Facilities

Choosing the right location for your small business in Valley Cottage, NY is crucial, as it can greatly impact your success. Consider factors such as foot traffic, accessibility, competition, and proximity to your target market. Research available commercial spaces, whether it’s a storefront, office, or warehouse, and negotiate favorable lease terms. Depending on your product/service type, you must choose the location. If you are starting Delivery services in Valley Cottage, you must choose the location where you get the most appropriate customers/buyers.

If your business operates primarily online, ensure you have a reliable website and a strong online presence to reach your customers effectively. Invest in e-commerce platforms and digital marketing strategies to drive traffic and generate sales.

Step 5: Get Permits and Licenses

After registering your business, you need to apply for permits and licenses to conduct the business in Valley Cottage. You must check with New York Secretary of State for proper license requirements. Permits can be received from the local county office or city office.

For the licenses, you can check the New York Business Licenses to know what type of licenses you need for your business.

Step 6: Branding and Marketing

Develop a compelling brand identity that resonates with your target audience. Create a memorable business name that is not used by any other company in Valley Cottage or New York state, design a professional logo, and craft a consistent visual identity across all marketing materials. Establish your online presence through social media channels, a business website, and relevant online directories.

Craft a comprehensive marketing strategy that includes both traditional and digital marketing tactics. Utilize local advertising, sponsor community events in Valley Cottage, and collaborate with influencers or Valley Cottage local media outlets to generate buzz around your business. Consider offering promotions or discounts to attract new customers and build brand loyalty.

Step 7: Hiring and Team Building

As your business grows, you may need to hire employees to help manage day-to-day operations. Define the roles and responsibilities required for your business and develop a hiring process to attract qualified candidates. Comply with employment laws and regulations, such as minimum wage requirements and workplace safety guidelines. Invest in team-building activities to foster a positive work environment and encourage employee collaboration. Happy and motivated employees contribute to better customer service and overall business success.

Step 8: Continuous Learning and Adaptation

Starting a small business is an ongoing learning process. Stay informed about industry trends, changes in consumer behavior, and new technologies that can enhance your business operations. Attend workshops, conferences, and networking events to connect with other entrepreneurs and gain valuable insights.

Remain flexible and willing to adapt your business strategies based on market feedback and customer preferences. Regularly assess your business performance, review your financials, and make adjustments as necessary to ensure long-term success.

Cost of Starting a Small Business in Valley Cottage

The main cost one has to bear is the filing cost. In New York, the cost of filing a business depends on the business structure. If you are starting an LLC in Valley Cottage, the cost of filing it is $200 (by mail and $208 online). On the other side, if you’re setting up a corporation in Valley Cottage, the filing cost is $125 for filing online, or by mail. This fee is mandatory and has to be paid at the time of filing the company.

llc-cost

Apart from the state filing fee, there is a registered agent fee, operating agreement fee, and other documentation fees to be paid. These are variable costs and depend solely on the state and city you’re starting your business. The other costs are licenses, permits, and special permission fees set by the Valley Cottage local government or county authorities. You must check with the local city offices for the exact amount to be paid before or after you set up your small business in Valley Cottage. Read New York LLC Cost if you want to start an LLC in Valley Cottage, New York.

Other Useful Stats about Valley Cottage, NY

City NameValley Cottage
State NameNew York
State IDNY
State CapitalAlbany
City Population8749
Population Density (per sq. miles)778
County NamesRockland
% of Male Population49.3%
% of Female Population50.7%
% of People in their 20s10.9%
% of People in their 30s10.9%
% of People in their 40s11.6%
% of People in their 50s17.8%
% of People in their 60s15.7%
% of People in their 70s11%
% of People above 80s5.5%
Average Individual Income 57983
% of People owned own home90.6%
Labour Force Participation62.7
Unemployment Rate6.9
Poverty Rate2.4%

FAQs

What is the population of Valley Cottage, NY?
The population of Valley Cottage, NY is approximately 9,107 as of the latest census data.
Are there any parks or recreational areas in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, Valley Cottage has several parks and recreational areas, including Blauvelt State Park and Rockland Lake State Park.
How many small businesses are there in Valley Cottage, NY?
The exact number of small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY is constantly changing, but there are a variety of local establishments catering to different needs in the area.
Are there any specialty stores in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, Valley Cottage is home to a number of specialty stores that offer unique products and services, catering to various interests and needs.
Are there any local food markets in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, Valley Cottage has a few local food markets that offer a variety of produce, groceries, and specialty food items.
What are some popular attractions in Valley Cottage, NY?
Some popular attractions in Valley Cottage, NY include the Hudson Valley Llamas farm, the Valley Cottage Library, and the Joe Whitten Memorial Park.
Is Valley Cottage, NY a good place to start a small business?
Valley Cottage can be a favorable location to start a small business, as it offers a supportive community, a decent population, and proximity to the larger city of New York.
How can I find information about small business grants or loans available in Valley Cottage, NY?
To find information about small business grants or loans available in Valley Cottage, NY, you can reach out to the local Chamber of Commerce, check with the Small Business Administration, or consult with a financial advisor specializing in small businesses.
What are some popular small business industries in Valley Cottage, NY?
Some popular small business industries in Valley Cottage, NY include restaurants, retail stores, professional services like accounting and legal firms, and health and wellness establishments.
Are there any networking events for small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, there are networking events for small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY. It’s worth checking with the local Chamber of Commerce or industry-specific associations for event listings.
Can you recommend any co-working spaces in Valley Cottage, NY?
While Valley Cottage may not have dedicated co-working spaces, there are some nearby areas such as Nyack and Westchester that offer co-working spaces you can consider.
Are there any local organizations that provide mentoring or support for small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, there are organizations in Valley Cottage, NY, and the surrounding areas that provide mentoring and support for small business owners, such as SCORE and local business development centers.
Are there any local business training programs available in Valley Cottage, NY?
Valley Cottage may offer occasional business training programs through the local Chamber of Commerce or community centers. It’s recommendable to check with those organizations for any upcoming programs.
Where can I find information about Valley Cottage, NY local ordinances and regulations that may apply to my small business?
To find information about local ordinances and regulations in Valley Cottage, NY, it is advisable to contact the Valley Cottage Town Hall or the local zoning department.
What resources are available for women-owned small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY?
Some resources available for women-owned small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY include networking groups like Women’s Business Enterprise National Council (WBENC) and local women entrepreneur associations.
Are there any business incubators or innovation hubs in Valley Cottage, NY?
While Valley Cottage itself may not have business incubators or innovation hubs, nearby areas within Rockland County and Westchester County might have such facilities available.
How can I promote my small business in Valley Cottage, NY?
To promote your small business in Valley Cottage, NY, you can utilize various marketing tactics such as social media advertising, local print media, community events, and participating in local business directories.
What are some popular marketing strategies for small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY?
Popular marketing strategies for small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY include social media marketing, email marketing, search engine optimization (SEO), and hosting community-focused events.
Are there any low-cost advertising options for small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, some low-cost advertising options for small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY include utilizing social media platforms, leveraging local partnerships, participating in local events, and optimizing digital marketing efforts.
How can I find potential customers in Valley Cottage, NY?
To find potential customers in Valley Cottage, NY, you can utilize social media targeting, conduct local market research, participate in community events, and create relevant content that appeals to local residents.
How can I attract tourists to my small business in Valley Cottage, NY?
To attract tourists to your small business in Valley Cottage, NY, consider promoting unique offerings, partnering with local tourist attractions, participating in tourism campaigns and directories, and utilizing digital marketing techniques that target potential visitors.
Are there any business-friendly resources available in Valley Cottage, NY?
In Valley Cottage, NY, you can find resources such as the Valley Cottage Chamber of Commerce, local business support organizations, networking groups, and government agencies offering assistance.
How can I connect with other small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY?
To connect with other small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY, you can attend local networking events, join industry-specific associations in the area, and utilize social media platforms.
Are there any tax incentives for small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY?
There may be tax incentives available for small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY, including tax breaks for certain industries or revitalization programs. Contact your local tax authority or speak with a tax professional for more information.
How can I find employees for my small business in Valley Cottage, NY?
To find employees for your small business in Valley Cottage, NY, you can advertise job openings on online job boards, utilize local recruitment agencies, spread the word through your network, and showcase vacancies on your business website and social media.
What resources are available for minority-owned small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY?
Resources available for minority-owned small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY include the Minority Business Development Agency, the New York State Division of Minority and Women-Owned Business Development, and local support organizations focused on diversity and inclusion.
How can I ensure my small business complies with local regulations in Valley Cottage, NY?
To ensure your small business complies with local regulations in Valley Cottage, NY, consult with local authorities, attend workshops or seminars on compliance, reach out to legal professionals specializing in small business regulations, and stay updated on any new ordinances or regulations.
Are there any business training workshops or seminars in Valley Cottage, NY?
Valley Cottage, NY may occasionally offer workshops or seminars through its Chamber of Commerce, local community centers, or educational institutions. Stay updated through event listings or by contacting these organizations.
Can I operate a home-based business in Valley Cottage, NY?
Depending on the nature of your business and local zoning regulations, you may be able to operate a home-based business in Valley Cottage, NY. It is advisable to check with the Valley Cottage Town Hall or zoning department to ensure compliance.
What are some popular small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY?
Some popular small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY include Valley Cottage Cafe, Valley Cottage Deli, and Valley Cottage Pizza and Pasta.
How can I start a small business in Valley Cottage, NY?
To start a small business in Valley Cottage, NY, you need to come up with a solid business plan, register your business with the state, obtain the necessary permits and licenses, and find a suitable location.
Are there any local networking events for small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, the Valley Cottage Chamber of Commerce often organizes networking events for small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY.
Are there any resources available to help small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, the Small Business Development Center at Rockland Community College provides resources and assistance to small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY.
What are the advantages of starting a small business in Valley Cottage, NY?
Some advantages of starting a small business in Valley Cottage, NY include the supportive local community, a favorable business environment, and a convenient location near major highways.
Are there any grants or funding options specifically available for small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, some grants and funding options are available for small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY through government programs and local business organizations.
What are the main industries represented by small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY?
Small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY are involved in various industries including food services, retail, healthcare, professional services, and hospitality.
Does Valley Cottage, NY have any business support organizations?
Yes, Valley Cottage has organizations like the Valley Cottage Chamber of Commerce that provide support and assistance to local businesses.
Are there any specific business regulations I should be aware of in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, it is important to familiarize yourself with local zoning regulations, licensing requirements, health and safety standards, and any other relevant business regulations in Valley Cottage, NY.
Is there a strong sense of community among small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY?
Absolutely! Small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY often support each other through collaboration, networking, and joint marketing initiatives.
Can I find affordable commercial properties to rent for my small business in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, there are various commercial properties available for rent in Valley Cottage, NY that cater to small businesses with affordable leasing options.
Are there any local business opportunities for entrepreneurs in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, Valley Cottage, NY offers various local business opportunities for entrepreneurs, such as providing niche products or services that are in demand within the community.
Does Valley Cottage, NY have a local business directory?
Yes, Valley Cottage, NY has a local business directory that can be found online or through the Valley Cottage Chamber of Commerce.
Are there any specific tax incentives for small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY?
While there may be some tax incentives available on a state or federal level, it is recommended to consult with a tax professional for details specific to Valley Cottage, NY.
What are some other nearby towns or cities that small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY can connect with?
Small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY can connect with neighboring towns and cities such as Nyack, Nanuet, and Spring Valley.
Is Valley Cottage, NY a good location for retail businesses?
Yes, Valley Cottage, NY can be a great location for retail businesses due to its proximity to major highways and the presence of a supportive local community.
Are there any local resources that offer business training and workshops in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, the Small Business Development Center at Rockland Community College often offers business training and workshops for small business owners in Valley Cottage, NY.
How can I stay updated on local business news in Valley Cottage, NY?
You can stay updated on local business news in Valley Cottage, NY by reading local newspapers, following local business organizations on social media, and joining community mailing lists.
What are some upcoming festivals or events in Valley Cottage, NY that my small business can participate in?
Valley Cottage, NY hosts events like the Valley Cottage Street Fair, the Farmers Market, and various holiday celebrations where small businesses can participate and showcase their products or services.
Is there a support system or mentorship program available for aspiring entrepreneurs in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, aspiring entrepreneurs in Valley Cottage, NY can seek mentorship and guidance through programs organized by the Small Business Development Center at Rockland Community College or local business organizations.
Are there any co-working spaces or shared office spaces available for small businesses in Valley Cottage, NY?
While Valley Cottage, NY may not have dedicated co-working spaces, small businesses can explore shared office space options or consider leasing flexible office spaces in the area.
Are there any local delivery services available in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, there are some local delivery services available in Valley Cottage, NY that cater to small businesses, such as courier services or specialized delivery providers.
Are there any local marketing agencies or consultants in Valley Cottage, NY that can help me with my small business?
Yes, there are marketing agencies and consultants in Valley Cottage, NY who specialize in assisting small businesses with their marketing strategies and initiatives.
Can I start a home-based small business in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, you can start a home-based small business in Valley Cottage, NY as long as you comply with any applicable zoning ordinances and obtain the necessary permits and licenses.
Are there any community programs that support local businesses in Valley Cottage, NY?
Yes, Valley Cottage, NY has community programs such as “Shop Local” campaigns or initiatives to promote and support local businesses.
How can I find qualified employees for my small business in Valley Cottage, NY?
You can find qualified employees for your small business in Valley Cottage, NY by advertising job openings through online job boards, local community websites, or by networking with local educational institutions.
Is Valley Cottage, NY a tourist-friendly destination for small businesses?
While Valley Cottage, NY may not be a major tourist destination, certain types of small businesses like bed and breakfasts, cafes, or specialty shops can benefit from the local and seasonal tourist traffic.
How can I expand my small business in Valley Cottage, NY?
You can expand your small business in Valley Cottage, NY by conducting market research, expanding your product or service offerings, exploring new target markets, or considering partnerships or collaborations with other local businesses.

How Fast Can You Start a Small Business in Valley Cottage, NY

With every passing year, Valley Cottage cements its place as a welcoming hub for new businesses. The town’s lively entrepreneurial spirit, coupled with the ease of doing business, makes it an appealing destination for those seeking to launch a small enterprise. Unlike many other places, Valley Cottage embraces its local talents and encourages them to realize their dreams.

One of the most remarkable aspects of Valley Cottage is its thriving business community, which acts as a catalyst for new ventures. The ability to network and collaborate with like-minded individuals can significantly expedite the process of starting a small business. Valley Cottage boasts various business associations and incubation centers that foster continuous interaction, promoting innovation and growth. The area’s supportive ecosystem provides a nurturing environment for budding entrepreneurs and bolsters their chance of success.

In addition to a thriving business community, Valley Cottage offers abundant resources and support services for those starting a small business. Local administration and municipality offices have streamlined processes to ensure a smooth journey for entrepreneurs. From obtaining licenses and permits to understanding zoning regulations, Valley Cottage aims to simplify bureaucratic procedures and minimize hurdles along the way. This proficiency enables entrepreneurs to focus on developing and executing their business ideas rather than bureaucratic red tape.

Access to capital and financial assistance is an integral part of starting any business. In Valley Cottage, there is no shortage of options available to entrepreneurs seeking financial support. The town has a diverse range of investors, venture capitalists, and lending institutions eager to invest in promising new ventures. Additionally, initiatives and programs, such as low-interest business loans and grants, are provided to further encourage entrepreneurship. This financial backing significantly accelerates the process of starting a small business, decreasing the time it takes to turn an idea into a reality.

No conversation about starting a small business in Valley Cottage would be complete without mentioning the vibrant customer base present in the area. With its mix of local residents, tourists, and visitors, Valley Cottage provides a diverse market for various industries. The local population has a reputation for being receptive to new businesses, often championing their success. This encouraging clientele boosts the confidence of entrepreneurs, increasing their determination to establish themselves swiftly and effectively.

Ultimately, Valley Cottage, NY, stands out as a prime location for starting a small business. Its flourishing business community, supportive ecosystem, streamlined processes, availability of capital, and receptive customer base all contribute to a conducive environment crucial for a successful venture. With the right idea, passion, and dedication, entrepreneurs can expedite the process of setting up their business in Valley Cottage, setting themselves up for a bright and prosperous future.

Conclusion

Starting a small business in Valley Cottage requires careful planning, dedication, and hard work. By following these steps and seeking guidance from local resources, you can lay a solid foundation for your entrepreneurial journey. Remember, success often comes with perseverance and a willingness to learn from both triumphs and setbacks. Good luck with your entrepreneurial endeavors in Valley Cottage!

Leave a Comment