LLC vs. S Corp in New York 2024: A Comprehensive Comparison

by
LLC vs. S Corp in New York: Understanding the Differences

Embarking on the entrepreneurial journey in New York, also known as The Empire State, is an exciting and transformative experience. New York LLC and S Corporation are two popular options that often top the list of considerations for entrepreneurs. This article serves as your comprehensive guide, comparing LLC vs. S Corp in New York and ultimately assisting you in determining the best fit for you.

Dive into business formation with confidence and clarity as LLCBase expert analysis simplifies the complexities of LLCs and S Corps, shedding light on their unique advantages and drawbacks. So, let’s explore the fascinating world of LLCs and S Corps and set your business on the path to success in New York.

Compare LLC and S-Corp

What are an LLC and an S-Corp

A Limited Liability Company (LLC) is a popular legal business structure that offers a combination of benefits from both corporations and partnerships. It is specifically designed to provide personal asset protection to its owners, known as members. This protection ensures that the owner’s personal assets are separate from the business liabilities, such as debts and lawsuits.

In New York, forming an LLC involves several steps, including paying an initial filing fee. Additionally, LLCs in New York are required to pay an annual fee of $4.50 to maintain their legal status and stay compliant with the state regulations.

An LLC in New York offers an attractive option for entrepreneurs seeking a flexible business structure with added liability protection and favorable tax treatment.

Recommended: If you want to start an LLC in New York, an LLC Formation Service can help you be successful in this endeavor! We recommend –

Our #1 Pick: LegalZoom – ($0 + State Fees) Online LLC Setup

On the other hand, an S-Corporation, or S-Corp, is not a separate legal business entity like an LLC. Rather, it is a tax classification that existing corporations and LLCs can elect. A business can bypass double taxation by opting for this tax status, as the profits and losses are directly passed through to the owner’s personal tax return. Starting an S Corp in New York  allows business owners to report and pay taxes on their business income as part of their individual income tax filings, eliminating the need for separate corporate taxes.

In New York, it is crucial for business owners considering this tax classification to fully understand the implications and requirements of being an S-Corp in New York. This includes adhering to specific rules and regulations related to ownership, shareholder limits, and tax filing deadlines. If you want to start an S-Corp, LegalZoom will help you every step of the way!

LLCs and S-Corporations Comparison

Let’s explore the comparison between LLCs and S-Corporations to help you make an informed decision.

1. Taxation Differences in New York

One of the main differences between LLCs and S-Corporations in New York lies in how they are taxed. LLCs are typically subject to pass-through taxation, meaning the business profits and losses are reported on the owner’s personal tax return. In contrast, S-Corporations must adhere to specific tax requirements, including distributing salaries to shareholders and adhering to the state’s income tax rate.

  • Federal Taxes: When choosing between an LLC or S-Corporation in New York, it’s essential to consider several federal tax factors. These factors include differences in Pass-Through Taxes and Self-Employment Taxes.
  • Pass-Through Taxes: Both LLCs and S-Corporations in New York benefit from pass-through taxation at the federal level. Due to pass-through taxation, these entities do not pay federal income taxes as separate legal entities. Instead, their owners are required to pay federal income taxes on their share of the business income. This type of taxation prevents the company from being taxed twice. In contrast, C-Corporations in New York are subject to double taxation, meaning they must pay federal taxes at the entity level and their owners’ taxes.
  • Self-Employment Taxes: Many LLC owners in New York opt for S-Corporation taxation to reduce their self-employment taxes. An S-Corporation owner is not considered self-employed; they can become an employee of the company and receive regular salary benefits. Conversely, an LLC member must include their guaranteed payments and a portion of the LLC’s earnings when calculating their self-employment tax. Share distributions determine the corporate income of S-Corporation shareholders. For example, suppose you are the sole owner of an LLC in New York with an annual profit of $150,000 and a fair wage for someone in your location doing the same job as you is $100,000. Under the default LLC taxation, you must pay self-employment taxes on the $150,000 profit. However, if your company is taxed as an S-Corp in New York, you would be responsible for paying payroll taxes only on the $100,000 standard wage. Income tax would still apply to the remaining $50,000.
  • New York State Taxes: No major tax differences exist between regular LLCs and S-Corporation LLCs at the state level. For filing an annual report in New York, it costs $4.50, which can be paid to the NC Secretary of State. Additionally, before forming the LLC, you must pay $200 (by mail and online).

On the other hand, if you form an S-Corporation in New York, you will also need to pay taxes. This includes the S-Corp filing fee and an annual report fee after establishing your S-Corp for one year. You must also go to the NC Secretary of State to make these payments.

2. Liability Protection

LLCs and S-Corporations in New York provide liability protection for their owners. This means that the owner’s personal assets are protected from business debts and lawsuits. However, S-Corporation status does not offer the same level of protection as an LLC, as it is primarily a tax designation.

The following factors exclude certain individuals and entities from becoming shareholders in an S-Corporation in New York:

  • Insurance businesses
  • Domestic international sales corporations
  • Partnerships
  • Corporations
  • Unauthorized immigrants
  • Specific financial institutions

While understanding the ownership requirements of LLCs and S-Corporations in New York is essential, seeking legal counsel when establishing your business is still advisable. For assistance with your New York LLC or New York S-Corp, consider consulting with professionals.

3. Ownership Requirements and Restrictions

LLCs and S-Corporations in New York have specific ownership requirements and restrictions. For instance, an LLC can have unlimited members, while an S-Corporation is limited to 100 shareholders. Additionally, S-Corporations can only have one class of stock and must follow strict rules regarding shareholder eligibility.

Easier to File in New York: LLCs or S-Corporations

While filing an LLC or S-Corporation in New York requires time and preparation, proper planning can make the process manageable. Both LLCs and S-Corporations can be filed through the New York Resident Agent.

To start an LLC in New York, you must submit the Articles of Organization to the New York Secretary of State. This document should contain all the necessary information for your LLC, along with the payment of the associated filing fee.

On the other hand, if you want to elect S-Corporation status for your New York LLC, you will need to submit additional paperwork. First, file Form 8832 with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to indicate your preference to tax your LLC as a corporation rather than a partnership. Next, submit Form 2553 to choose S-Corporation status.

Remember, maintaining legal compliance is crucial for your LLC. This means submitting annual tax returns and reports after establishing your business entity.

With that, we’ve carefully curated a list of the best LLC services in New York to support and guide you through filing an LLC and S-Corp. Check them out!

LLC Services

Rating & Pricing

Top Features

Learn More

#1 Editor's Choice
Legalzoom

$0 + State Filing Fee

  • Free LLC Formation

  • Various Legal Services

  • Attorney Advice

Learn More

$299 + State Filing Fee

  • Single Package

  • Flat Pricing

  • Legal Services

Learn More

Filing Process for LLCs vs. S-Corporations in New York

Forming an LLC in New York involves several crucial steps. To start, you must file Articles of Organization with the New York Department of State and pay the associated filing fee of $200 (by mail and online). Once your LLC is established, you must comply with annual reporting and tax requirements.

On the other hand, if you want to elect an S-Corporation status for your existing LLC or corporation, the process is slightly different. Firstly, you must file Form 8832 with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to classify your LLC as a corporation for tax purposes. Then, you must submit Form 2553 to the IRS to choose S-Corporation status. In New York, the S-Corporation filing fee is $125 for filing online, or by mail..

Recommended: Maximize your business success in New York – hire a reliable LLC Formation Service for effortless LLC and S-Corp filings. Transform your entrepreneurial aspirations today!

Our #1 Pick: LegalZoom – ($0 + State Fees) Online LLC Setup

The LLC formation and S-Corporation election processes can be completed through two methods, online and by mail. Online incorporation is available at Create an account/Log in to the SOS site, get the online form, fill it, and submit online, while offline incorporation can be done at Send the form by mail to Department of State Division of Corporations, State Records and Uniform Commercial Code, One Commerce Plaza, 99 Washington Ave., Albany, NY 12231.. It is essential to stay up-to-date with any ongoing reporting and tax requirements for your chosen business structure.

The filing process for LLCs and S-Corporations in New York varies slightly, with each requiring specific forms and fees. It’s essential to consider the unique requirements of each business structure before making a decision. Consulting with a legal or financial advisor can provide valuable guidance on which structure best suits your business in New York.

FAQs

What is an S Corp in New York?
An S Corporation in New York is a small business that has filed Form 2553 with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), electing to be treated as a pass-through tax entity for federal tax purposes.
What is an LLC in New York?
An LLC in New York is a hybrid business entity that combines the liability protection of a corporation with the tax benefits of a pass-through entity.
How are LLCs taxed in New York?
LLCs in New York are treated as pass-through entities for tax purposes, meaning that the profits and losses of the business flow through to the personal tax returns of the individual owners.
How are S Corps taxed in New York?
S Corps in New York are also treated as pass-through entities for tax purposes, with the profits and losses of the business passing through to the individual tax returns of the owners.
Can an LLC be taxed as an S Corp in New York?
Yes, an LLC in New York can elect to be taxed as an S Corp for federal tax purposes by filing Form 8832 with the IRS.
What is the difference between an S Corp and an LLC in New York?
The main difference between an S Corp and an LLC in New York lies in their ownership and taxation structures. S Corps have more restrictive ownership requirements and must file an annual tax return with the IRS, while LLCs have more flexible ownership requirements and file taxes similar to sole proprietorships.
Can an S Corp have more than one class of stock in New York?
No, S Corps in New York are limited to having one class of stock.
Can an LLC have more than one class of membership units in New York?
Yes, LLCs in New York can have multiple classes of membership units, allowing owners to customize their investment and control rights.
What is the filing fee for an S Corp in New York?
The filing fee for an S Corp in New York is $155, as of 2021.
What is the filing fee for an LLC in New York?
The filing fee for an LLC in New York is $200, as of 2021.
Are there annual fees for S Corps in New York?
Yes, S Corps in New York must file a biennial report and pay a fee of $9 for each shareholder, as of 2021.
Are there annual fees for LLCs in New York?
Yes, LLCs in New York must file a biennial report and pay a fee of $9 for each member or foreign authorization filing, as of 2021.
Can non-residents own a share in an S Corp or LLC in New York?
Yes, non-residents can own shares in both S Corps and LLCs in New York.
Is there a limit to the number of owners in an S Corp or LLC in New York?
S Corps in New York can have a maximum of 100 shareholders, while there is no limit on the number of owners in an LLC.
Are there residency requirements for officers or managers of S Corps or LLCs in New York?
No, there are no residency requirements for officers or managers of S Corps and LLCs in New York.
Can an S Corp or LLC in New York have foreign ownership?
Yes, both S Corps and LLCs in New York can have foreign ownership.
Which type of business organization provides more liability protection, an S Corp or LLC in New York?
Both S Corps and LLCs in New York offer limited liability protection, meaning that the owners’ personal assets are generally protected from the debts and liabilities of the business.
Can an S Corp or LLC in New York change its taxation status?
Yes, both S Corps and LLCs in New York can elect to change their taxation status by filing the required forms with the IRS.
Are there any restrictions on the types of businesses that can be formed as LLCs or S Corps in New York?
No, most types of businesses can be formed as LLCs or S Corps in New York, although certain professions such as doctors and lawyers may have more specific requirements.
Are there any additional regulatory requirements for S Corps or LLCs in New York?
Yes, both S Corps and LLCs in New York must comply with state-specific business laws, in addition to federal regulations.
How are foreign LLCs treated in New York?
Foreign LLCs must register with the New York Department of State and file annual reports in order to transact business in New York.
How are foreign S Corps treated in New York?
Foreign S Corps must register with the New York Department of State and obtain a Certificate of Authority to do business in New York.
Are there any federal or state tax incentives to form an S Corp or LLC in New York?
Both S Corps and LLCs in New York may qualify for certain tax incentives, such as deductions for start-up or research and development costs.
Are there any state-specific tax incentives to form an S Corp or LLC in New York?
Yes, New York offers various tax credits and incentives to encourage business development and growth.
How long does it take to form an S Corp or LLC in New York?
The time it takes to form an S Corp or LLC in New York depends on various factors such as the complexity of the business and the filing methods used, but it typically takes at least a few weeks.
Can an S Corp or LLC be formed online in New York?
Yes, both S Corps and LLCs in New York can be formed online using the New York Department of State’s business formation website.
How can I provide liability protection for my personal assets in New York?
By forming an LLC or S Corp in New York, you can limit personal liability for business debts and legal actions.
Which type of business organization is right for my business in New York?
The best choice between an S Corp or LLC for your business in New York depends on your specific circumstances, such as the number and type of owners, tax situation, and growth plans.
What are some of the differences between LLCs and S Corporations in New York?
LLCs offer investors more flexibility than an S Corp. S Corps are limited to 100 shareholders and require unanimous shareholder consent to make certain decisions. LLCs don’t have a limit on the number of member owned in New York.
What is an S Corporation in New York?
An S Corporation is a legal structure that allows for a hybrid between a partnership and a corporation for tax purposes.
What are the advantages of forming an LLC in New York versus an S Corp?
LLCs offer more flexibility for profit sharing distribution in New York and don’t require some of the formal requirements and bylaws that an S Corp would need.
Can an LLC become taxed as an S Corporation in New York?
Yes, you can elect to have your LLC treated as an S Corp for tax purposes in New York.
Are there any limits to the tax benefits of an S Corporation in New York?
An S Corp in New York has an income limit of $250,000 if you are filing as an individual or $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly.
What taxes do LLCs and S Corporations pay in New York?
LLCs and S Corps in New York typically pay state and federal income taxes, sales and property taxes in New York.
What is the cost difference between setting up an LLC versus an S Corp, in New York?
The filing fee to create an LLC is $200 in New York and to set up an S Corp is $125.
What is the accounting method an LLC must use in New York when preparing taxes?
In New York, LLCs can either choose to use the cash or accrual method to prepare their taxes.
How are LLCs and S Corps taxed differently in New York?
LLCs in New York can be taxed like a partnership, sole proprietorship, C corporation, or S corporation. An S Corp has different tax treatment than an LLC also called an Ah-change société.
Can an LLC in New York raise capital through the sale of stock like an S Corp can?
No, LLCs in New York cannot sell stock since all members must display equal profit distribution.
Can a foreign national hold ownership in an LLC/S Corp in New York?
Yes, foreign nationals are allowed to be owners or members of an LLC or S Corp in New York.
What legal status do LLCs and S Corps in New York have in regards to liabilities and taxes?
Both LLCs and S Corps offer their members or shareholders liability protection in New York. For taxes, the income reported in reporting period doesn’t get taxed unless the company should change its entity status.
Is it possible to convert from an LLC to an S Corp in New York?
Yes, an LLC can convert to an S Corp in New York when it is eligible.
How frequently is an LLC taxed in New York?
Depends on whether the LLC is single or multi-member using the reports providing exact residual amounts for the owners’ long term gains or loses.
Can I have a single member S Corp in New York?
No, an S Corporation must have at the least two shareholders or sometimes depending on ownership voting there may be a need to evaluate key players of ownership as well.
What kind of businesses generally form an S Corp in New York?
In New York it is typical in legal, medical profession, small enterprise owning rental real estate, ownership of developmental lands, e.t.c.
What are the steps to set up an LLC in New York?
To set up an LLC in New York requires one to register with the New York Division of Corporations and file your LLC Formation Documents, ask for explicit details when attaning your current file from the NYC offices.
What are the steps to set up an S Corp in New York?
In New York, forming an S Corp requires electing one stand-in president, corporative type C articles. The aboven could fluctuate due to the comapnies preference.
How many shares can an S Corp include according to the New York law?
New York Law loves between one and two million S shares, par values to bucks maybe shall amounting up to $10 million every share catagory.
What are the annual fees for S Corps in New York?
The annual filing fee presently here and now is $125 in New York compared to a maintenance fee for the federal in the US.
Are there formal establishment agreements related to the S Corps formation in New York required?
Establish agreements endow key management provisions bearing detailed responsibilities, actions, elimination reasons, e.t.c dependent on the party registered motivations
Can a partnership apply as an S Corp in New York?
Partnership businesses that have citizens acts and doing businesses in New York go with their private state tax code selection preferences honestly adopted directed by conversions.
Have federal tax rates altered bonus depreciation for EDC material emittance among entity types in New York?
Congress has approved of thousands depreciation allocation forms; added capitalized venture assets to elective changes applying to info system chains.
Do all states in the USA recognize S Corps the same as New York state?
Nationally interchanging amongst intise laws instituted in each state, scoring rank attributes, allocations needs as anticipated to New York territorial liberties observation statements employed.
Can corporations apply for New York S Corp status?
Usually S Corps are adopted earlier into application, since definitely split pay process is timed purposefully unless willing leaders hold of instate partnerships.
Is it mandatory for S Corps to hold regular meetings following initial structuration in New York?
Fitting all vital enaliensis according and to state laws associates have work purpose under thorough capituizations established after composing the original 154 as required. Partnerships that have other types of approach of allowable councilors.(potentially confidential)
Can LLCs form signatory binding handling for controlled securities that are blue powder file corporations through S Corps protocols in new york?
Limited liability cail1icityaries with corporation statutes sign to incure to go public within an algorithm is incorporated signed LLC S collective partis of registrations. However, are instuctively read to prevent aye investments counted towards intended regulation of control securities blue powders, wrights added to S Corp but separate from separate taxes collected on personal ownership. (operative confindentiality)
Are S-Corps able to deduct health & dental employee premiums against state incomes in New York?
S-Corps located in New York are indeed able to deduct health and dental premiums from employee salery, invest not only for personal reduction, but also for business security and organizeably retains unique opportunities, tax savings paired with ease of acquiring and quouds.
Can LLC establish comprehensive resolutions eliminating GEMA private titles withdrawing exclusive representation and IP properties in New York?
LLC’s form with the motive of limiting members’ applied reconstructions inducing explicit reductions often incorporated under contracts. Upon GEMA works creating subsidiary organizations, specifications conveying eligibility of transfering income characteristics, engagement defining own specific labels.LLC law provides ‘Stat. #509-b’ path for New York misteries.

Also Read

Conclusion

Navigating the world of business structures and filings may seem daunting, but with the right information and guidance, you can confidently make the best decision for your unique entrepreneurial journey. Remember, the path to success is paved with well-informed choices and a clear understanding of your business goals. So, take the time to research, consult with professionals, and weigh the pros and cons of LLCs and S-Corporations in New York.

As you embark on this exciting adventure, remember that a strong foundation built on sound legal and financial principles will be the backbone of your thriving enterprise. Embrace the challenge, stay curious, and always remember your passion and vision. Visit LLCBase today to access valuable resources, expert guidance, and personalized support tailored to your needs. Don’t wait any longer – let us help you realize your entrepreneurial dreams. 

Leave a Comment